A lower payment can help a household get through renewal. It can also leave a much larger balance for the next renewal.
For a $400,000 mortgage renewed at a fixed 5% rate, stretching the repayment schedule from 20 years to 25 years reduces the monthly payment by about $302. After five years, however, the borrower would owe about $20,516 more than if they had kept the 20-year schedule.
That extra balance is not all extra interest. Most of it is principal the borrower has postponed repaying. In this example, the longer schedule adds about $2,392 of interest during the five-year term.
NorthScope News calculated 36 rate-and-balance renewal scenarios and nine comparisons of 20-, 25- and 30-year amortizations. These are transparent mathematical examples, not a borrower survey, lender offers or predictions of future rates.
What happens to a $400,000 mortgage at renewal?
Keeping 20 years remaining, a change from a 2% rate to 5% raises the modeled payment from $2,021.96 to $2,628.50 a month: an increase of $606.54, or approximately 30%. Both calculations use the same $400,000 balance at the comparison date. They do not compare an original loan amount with a smaller balance five years later.
| Rate scenario | Monthly payment | Change from 2% |
|---|---|---|
| 2% | $2,021.96 | $0.00 |
| 3% | $2,214.67 | $192.71 |
| 4% | $2,416.99 | $395.02 |
| 5% | $2,628.50 | $606.54 |
| 6% | $2,848.75 | $826.79 |
The rate on the renewal offer matters, but so does the time left to repay. Comparing the monthly payment alone can hide the difference between getting a better rate and taking longer to repay the same debt.
The cost of extending amortization to 25 or 30 years
| Amortization | Monthly payment | Debt after 5 years | Interest over 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 years | $2,628.50 | $333,513.61 | $91,223.61 |
| 25 years | $2,326.42 | $354,030.03 | $93,615.23 |
| 30 years | $2,134.76 | $367,046.84 | $95,132.60 |

Choosing 25 years instead of 20 frees up approximately $18,125 of cash over the next 60 payments. It also leaves approximately $20,516 more principal outstanding. The difference between those amounts is the additional interest paid during the term.
At 30 years, the payment falls by about $494 a month compared with the 20-year option. The balance after five years is about $33,533 higher, and interest over those five years is about $3,909 higher. The borrower arrives at the next renewal with more debt exposed to whatever rate is available then.
Those comparisons do not mean the shortest schedule is affordable for everyone. A household under cash-flow pressure may value a lower required payment. The useful question is how much breathing room it creates, what it costs, and whether there is a realistic plan to accelerate repayment later.
How the trade-off changes with the mortgage balance
| Balance at renewal | Monthly relief: 20 → 25 years | Extra debt after 5 years |
|---|---|---|
| $250,000 | $188.80 | $12,823 |
| $400,000 | $302.08 | $20,516 |
| $600,000 | $453.12 | $30,775 |
With the rate and repayment schedule unchanged, the results scale with the balance. A $600,000 balance produces 1.5 times the dollar effect of a $400,000 balance. That is why the amount owing on the renewal statement is a better starting point than the original purchase price.
Why Canadian borrowers are still watching renewals
In its May 2026 Financial Stability Report, the Bank of Canada projected an average payment increase of about 15% for the cohort of five-year fixed-payment mortgages renewing over the following 12 months. That estimate describes a particular group and uses the report’s assumptions; it is not a prediction for every borrower. NorthScope’s examples isolate individual rate, balance and amortization choices rather than estimating a national average.
Three numbers to compare before accepting a renewal
1. The required payment. Compare offers using the same amount owing, payment frequency and remaining amortization first. Then compare any proposed extension separately.
2. Interest and fees over the offered term. The payment includes both interest and principal. Ask for switching, discharge, appraisal and other charges that apply to the actual offer; this study excludes fees.
3. The balance at the end of the term. Ask what will still be owed at the next renewal, and how allowed extra payments would change that number. A lower required payment does not prevent every borrower from paying more, but the contract’s prepayment terms matter.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada recommends shopping around before renewal and explains that extending amortization can lower payments while increasing interest costs. Switching lenders or extending repayment may require approval and may involve costs. Check the actual contract and lender requirements rather than assuming that a 25- or 30-year option is available. Read FCAC’s renewal guidance.
Does the province change the calculation?
For the same balance, interest convention, payment frequency and amortization, the payment mathematics in this study does not change by province. Actual rates, fees, property circumstances and eligibility can differ. These examples therefore do not rank cities or claim to represent a typical Toronto, Vancouver or Canadian household.
Try your own balance and offered rate in the NorthScope mortgage renewal calculator. If you are buying rather than renewing, use the Canadian mortgage payment calculator, which also considers location-dependent purchase costs. More tools are available in Money Tools.
Turn the research into a decision
Compare 20- and 25-year renewal schedules, see when switching fees outweigh a lower rate, or explore our Canadian money research and practical guides.
Methodology and reproducible data
Calculated October 3, 2026. The renewal grid uses balances of $250,000, $400,000 and $600,000; remaining amortizations of 15, 20 and 25 years; and new rates of 3%, 4%, 5% and 6%. A 2% reference rate is used at the same balance and remaining amortization. The extension grid compares 20, 25 and 30 years at 4%, 5% and 6% for each balance. The grids are selected examples, not a representative sample of Canadian mortgages.
All rates are nominal annual rates compounded twice yearly. Payments occur monthly at month-end. With principal P, annual rate j expressed as a decimal, and y years remaining, the monthly rate is i = (1 + j/2)1/6 − 1 and the payment is A = Pi / [1 − (1 + i)−12y]. After 60 payments, the balance is B = P(1 + i)60 − A[(1 + i)60 − 1]/i. Interest over that period is 60A − (P − B).
Calculations retain full precision until display. Each result was cross-checked against a month-by-month amortization calculation. Lender rounding can create small differences. The model excludes fees, insurance, property taxes, prepayments and variable-rate changes, and makes no assumption about rates after the five-year comparison. It does not assess eligibility or recommend a specific mortgage.
View all 36 renewal scenarios
| Balance (CAD) | Rate | Years | Monthly payment | Debt after 5 years | Interest over 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000.00 | 3% | 15 | $1,724.22 | $178,722.05 | $32,175.31 |
| $250,000.00 | 4% | 15 | $1,845.10 | $182,522.56 | $43,228.37 |
| $250,000.00 | 5% | 15 | $1,970.31 | $186,203.35 | $54,421.92 |
| $250,000.00 | 6% | 15 | $2,099.71 | $189,759.44 | $65,741.86 |
| $250,000.00 | 3% | 20 | $1,384.17 | $200,694.96 | $33,745.16 |
| $250,000.00 | 4% | 20 | $1,510.62 | $204,679.80 | $45,316.76 |
| $250,000.00 | 5% | 20 | $1,642.81 | $208,446.00 | $57,014.76 |
| $250,000.00 | 6% | 20 | $1,780.47 | $211,990.43 | $68,818.69 |
| $250,000.00 | 3% | 25 | $1,183.11 | $213,686.51 | $34,673.34 |
| $250,000.00 | 4% | 25 | $1,315.05 | $217,634.79 | $46,537.82 |
| $250,000.00 | 5% | 25 | $1,454.01 | $221,268.77 | $58,509.52 |
| $250,000.00 | 6% | 25 | $1,599.52 | $224,591.76 | $70,562.75 |
| $400,000.00 | 3% | 15 | $2,758.75 | $285,955.27 | $51,480.49 |
| $400,000.00 | 4% | 15 | $2,952.15 | $292,036.09 | $69,165.39 |
| $400,000.00 | 5% | 15 | $3,152.50 | $297,925.36 | $87,075.07 |
| $400,000.00 | 6% | 15 | $3,359.53 | $303,615.10 | $105,186.97 |
| $400,000.00 | 3% | 20 | $2,214.67 | $321,111.94 | $53,992.25 |
| $400,000.00 | 4% | 20 | $2,416.99 | $327,487.67 | $72,506.82 |
| $400,000.00 | 5% | 20 | $2,628.50 | $333,513.61 | $91,223.61 |
| $400,000.00 | 6% | 20 | $2,848.75 | $339,184.68 | $110,109.91 |
| $400,000.00 | 3% | 25 | $1,892.98 | $341,898.42 | $55,477.34 |
| $400,000.00 | 4% | 25 | $2,104.08 | $348,215.66 | $74,460.51 |
| $400,000.00 | 5% | 25 | $2,326.42 | $354,030.03 | $93,615.23 |
| $400,000.00 | 6% | 25 | $2,559.23 | $359,346.82 | $112,900.41 |
| $600,000.00 | 3% | 15 | $4,138.13 | $428,932.91 | $77,220.73 |
| $600,000.00 | 4% | 15 | $4,428.23 | $438,054.14 | $103,748.08 |
| $600,000.00 | 5% | 15 | $4,728.74 | $446,888.04 | $130,612.61 |
| $600,000.00 | 6% | 15 | $5,039.30 | $455,422.65 | $157,780.45 |
| $600,000.00 | 3% | 20 | $3,322.01 | $481,667.92 | $80,988.38 |
| $600,000.00 | 4% | 20 | $3,625.48 | $491,231.51 | $108,760.24 |
| $600,000.00 | 5% | 20 | $3,942.75 | $500,270.41 | $136,835.42 |
| $600,000.00 | 6% | 20 | $4,273.13 | $508,777.02 | $165,164.86 |
| $600,000.00 | 3% | 25 | $2,839.47 | $512,847.63 | $83,216.01 |
| $600,000.00 | 4% | 25 | $3,156.12 | $522,323.49 | $111,690.77 |
| $600,000.00 | 5% | 25 | $3,489.63 | $531,045.04 | $140,422.84 |
| $600,000.00 | 6% | 25 | $3,838.84 | $539,020.23 | $169,350.61 |
View all nine amortization comparisons (three schedules each)
| Balance (CAD) | Rate | Years | Monthly payment | Debt after 5 years | Interest over 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000.00 | 4% | 20 | $1,510.62 | $204,679.80 | $45,316.76 |
| $250,000.00 | 4% | 25 | $1,315.05 | $217,634.79 | $46,537.82 |
| $250,000.00 | 4% | 30 | $1,188.80 | $225,998.31 | $47,326.11 |
| $250,000.00 | 5% | 20 | $1,642.81 | $208,446.00 | $57,014.76 |
| $250,000.00 | 5% | 25 | $1,454.01 | $221,268.77 | $58,509.52 |
| $250,000.00 | 5% | 30 | $1,334.23 | $229,404.27 | $59,457.88 |
| $250,000.00 | 6% | 20 | $1,780.47 | $211,990.43 | $68,818.69 |
| $250,000.00 | 6% | 25 | $1,599.52 | $224,591.76 | $70,562.75 |
| $250,000.00 | 6% | 30 | $1,487.06 | $232,423.13 | $71,646.64 |
| $400,000.00 | 4% | 20 | $2,416.99 | $327,487.67 | $72,506.82 |
| $400,000.00 | 4% | 25 | $2,104.08 | $348,215.66 | $74,460.51 |
| $400,000.00 | 4% | 30 | $1,902.07 | $361,597.29 | $75,721.78 |
| $400,000.00 | 5% | 20 | $2,628.50 | $333,513.61 | $91,223.61 |
| $400,000.00 | 5% | 25 | $2,326.42 | $354,030.03 | $93,615.23 |
| $400,000.00 | 5% | 30 | $2,134.76 | $367,046.84 | $95,132.60 |
| $400,000.00 | 6% | 20 | $2,848.75 | $339,184.68 | $110,109.91 |
| $400,000.00 | 6% | 25 | $2,559.23 | $359,346.82 | $112,900.41 |
| $400,000.00 | 6% | 30 | $2,379.29 | $371,877.00 | $114,634.62 |
| $600,000.00 | 4% | 20 | $3,625.48 | $491,231.51 | $108,760.24 |
| $600,000.00 | 4% | 25 | $3,156.12 | $522,323.49 | $111,690.77 |
| $600,000.00 | 4% | 30 | $2,853.11 | $542,395.93 | $113,582.66 |
| $600,000.00 | 5% | 20 | $3,942.75 | $500,270.41 | $136,835.42 |
| $600,000.00 | 5% | 25 | $3,489.63 | $531,045.04 | $140,422.84 |
| $600,000.00 | 5% | 30 | $3,202.14 | $550,570.26 | $142,698.90 |
| $600,000.00 | 6% | 20 | $4,273.13 | $508,777.02 | $165,164.86 |
| $600,000.00 | 6% | 25 | $3,838.84 | $539,020.23 | $169,350.61 |
| $600,000.00 | 6% | 30 | $3,568.94 | $557,815.50 | $171,951.93 |
Source for all scenario tables and chart: NorthScope News calculations. External sources provide context and consumer guidance; they did not produce or endorse this analysis.
Featured file photo: Scarborough Junction, March 2010, by SimonP / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0. Display may be cropped. The homes shown are illustrative.

